Jelly roll and Build xo Done. After Bonnie publicly said they “went through hell,” after she mentioned the infidelity out loud, after years of what seemed like one of the most memorable love stories in country music, the marriage ended.
The shots are already flying. I forgave him very quickly. It hasn’t really changed. She should have left years ago. He should have pleaded harder.
I want to slow it down. Because I’ve sat with a lot of couples who looked exactly like that on the outside. General reconciliation. General dedication. Tattoos, song lyrics, anniversary posts. And then, quietly, a divorce was filed three or five years later.
There’s a reason why the phrase “we’re over it” doesn’t often stick. It has almost nothing to do with whether love is real.
The third person who never leaves
An affair, in terms of attachment, is not just a behavior. It is the entry of a third party into the underlying instrument. The basic bond is based on two beliefs that your nervous system needs to feel safe: I am your priority. I am enough for you.
An affair tells your partner’s body, in one fell swoop, that both of these things are in question. This is not a condo. This is a check of the body for danger.
People also misunderstand the extent of the wound. They believe that an affair is one betrayal. It’s hardly the case. There’s the issue itself, and then six or seven sub-infections that live within it. You lied to my face. You made me feel stupid. I took her to the restaurant which we said was ours. You said you loved me one night and now I know you were texting her. You had a whole life where I didn’t.
Furthermore, the betrayed partner loses his or her grip on reality. They look at the last vacation, the last anniversary, the last “I love you,” and they can’t tell what’s real. This is a kind of vertigo.
Now add the harshest part. The person they feel is the person who hurt them is also the person they yearn for relief from. This is really crazy, this is the room where Jelly Roll and Bonnie lived, and it’s the same room I see the couples sitting in every week.
The episode that eats up a marriage after three years
This is the dynamic I see destroying couples who have “done the work.”
They come to me after two, three, or sometimes five years of this relationship. They stayed. They are “fine”. They are posting again. Then an explosion occurs every few weeks. He’s late. He corners his phone. She is back in shock, asking questions again, her voice rising.
He sighs. He’s slipping. He says, “Oh my God, are we doing this again? I’ve apologized a thousand times.”
It explodes.
I call this the “Never Forget, Never Forgive” episode. He is the quiet killer of marriage after an affair. From the outside the eye roll looks like a guy who doesn’t care. I slow down the tape and see a terrified man. His nervous system does not hear the words “I need reassurance.” It’s hearing: “You’re bad. You’ll always be bad. No matter what you do, you’ll never be free from this.”
An eye roll is not arrogance. It’s despair. It is the breakdown of a person who feels he is serving a life sentence in his marriage.
If you want to know if you and your partner are sitting in the loop like this, get a free relationship assessment. Sometimes it’s easier to see a pattern when someone names it for you.
Why shame is the real killer of marriage
The biggest obstacle to repair after an affair is not a lack of love. It’s a shame.
The partner who has gone astray often drowns. They look at their partner’s tears, and this confirms their worst fears for themselves. I’m a monster. I am devastated. I don’t deserve it. So when their partner starts crying, or asking again, they collapse inside. “I can’t talk about this, I’m a piece of sh*tR.”
This collapse is a disaster. Because when you join in with “I’m bad,” you make the moment about you. You abandon your partner inside his pain for the second time. They are left alone in the explosion while you wallow in the guilt of lighting the fuse.
At the same time, the betrayed partner does not try to be punished. It comes true. Are you still here? Do you still get it? Is it safe? When he moves away, her security evaporates and her voice rises. She wants him to feel her pain so she knows she’s not crazy. This is classic attachment trauma, and the protest behaviors of both partners ensure that neither is satisfied.
What sounds better in my office isn’t “communicating more.” It’s specific.
First, you close the door. Completely. There is no ambiguity about the third party. You cannot perform surgery while the patient is still bleeding.
Second, stop the “we both contributed” frame. For a season, traffic flows in one direction. Someone dropped the bomb. The other stood in the explosion. Asking the betrayed partner to “own their part” too soon seems like gaslighting, because it is.
Third: The traitor must change the internal mixture. Right now, their cocktail is 100% “I feel bad about myself.” It should become 20% “I feel bad about myself” and 80% “My partner’s heart is broken and I’m going to be present with this without holding back.”
This third step is what breaks the cycle. This is a step that most couples never learn.
A line I wish I’d told them years ago
I don’t know Jelly Roll and Bunny. I won’t pretend. But I’ve seen this kind of ending a hundred times, and the love has never been real. The problem is that the loop has become too tired to continue working.
Tolerance is not a finish line you cross once. It’s a situation that two people have to keep choosing, on Tuesday, when no one’s watching, when you ask the question again and he has to decide what to do with his face.
_______________________________________________________________________________
Figs O’Sullivan, founder of Empathi, and his wife, Till, are San Francisco-based couples therapists, relationship experts at Stars and Silicon Valley, and founders of Empathi, and built Figlet, our AI relationship coach, an AI relationship coach trained in their clinical work.*
