Rooster movie review: HBO’s Steve Carell College comedy has an excellent cast, but can’t figure out what it wants to be

Logo text

Despite its massive cast and abundant, if sporadically used, charm, HBO Rooster He suffers from an abundance of logical lines and insufficient concentration in determining which ones he wants to follow. It’s a show that has a surplus of underdeveloped identities, rather than a lack of identity, and thrives on poorly combined story elements with humor that is sometimes catchy and often hopelessly trite.

Rooster It is the story of an introverted fantasy author (Steve Carell), whose masculine ego is nothing but gets a life-changing opportunity when he gets a job as writer-in-residence at a small New England college.

Or maybe…

Rooster It is the story of a successful novelist (Steve Carell) who never went to college, but gets a chance to recreate the student experience when he gets a job as writer-in-residence at a small college in New England.

Or maybe…

Rooster The film follows best-selling novelist (Steve Carell) who takes a job as writer-in-residence at a small New England college, and is reunited with his daughter (Charlie Clive), an art history professor who is dealing with a crumbling marriage.

Or maybe…

Steve Carell plays the title role Rooster As before [narrative element redacted] who lands a job as resident clerk at a small New England college, only to find his true calling when he somewhat confusingly becomes the school’s new principal. [narrative element redacted].

Or maybe…

A poetry teacher (Danielle Deadwyler) at a small New England college is looking forward to a reunion with her best friend, newly hired as writer-in-residence, only for the school’s president (John C. McGinley) to give the job to a lowly writer (Steve Carell) who doesn’t even want the job. They – the poet and the novelist – are about to get engaged. Complications ensue.

Well, to be clear, Rooster Certainly not the last show I mentioned, though that’s certainly a subplot — “an unassuming, completely unqualified, generally uninterested white man takes advantage of a black poet’s friend’s job” — and that’s part of Roosterthe show isn’t really equipped to handle it.

I wish it was! TV needs to stop treating Deadwyler like a condiment when the buffet is complete. Rooster Created by Bill Lawrence and Matt Tarses, I understand why they were interested in the side story about Dylan playing the Deadwyler but not interested enough to be the main show – especially with Steve Carell as the focus of the rest of the series. But a big part of me watched the six episodes that were sent to critics and wished Lawrence and Tarses would bring in Ashley Nicole Black to shepherd and direct the series. Black has worked with Lawrence on Shrink and Ted Lassoso she understands his brand of humor and broad emotions. She also has extensive experience as a graduate student, so she knows the world of academia in a way that Lawrence and Tarses somewhat clearly do not.

oh well. Deadwyler has just been named a captain in Ryan Coogler’s update of X-Filesso at least someone understands that she has to be “the show,” not someone you include in a supporting role to make the show better.

It’s not like the logical lines I’ve been through Rooster They’re different from each other, but they require different levels of plot, while it’s an almost universally acknowledged fact that Bill Lawrence’s shows generally work best when they ditch their gimmicks, or at least deemphasize them — “A woman in her 40s wants to date younger men” or “A grief-stricken psychiatrist does wildly unethical things” — and become just stories about damaged people hanging out, making mistakes, and cuddling.

It’s entirely possible that by the end of the 10-episode first season, Rooster You will find its story, resolve its most jarring parts, and become one of Bill Lawrence’s most charming and charming performances. What’s annoying about him Rooster So far, there’s little evidence that Greg Russo’s version of the story (that’s the name of Carell’s character, while “Rooster” is the name of his alter ego) is the one they needed to tell, and no evidence at all of what attracted them to the university setting.

For years, no one cared about the detail or depth of research in portraying the field, with “college professor” spending decades as a profession that TV writers found less interesting than “meth dealer,” “guy living in post-apocalyptic bunker” and “John Wayne Gacy.” But recently, there has been a renaissance of figures who can explain what the Renaissance is; between The chair, Lucky Hank and Vladimirwhich Netflix will release this weekend against RoosterThe job of “college professor” has become almost as common a fantasy job as “guy living in a post-apocalyptic bunker.” So you have to at least pretend you know what college will be like in 2026.

It’s all in Rooster Academically amorphous, from the type of Ludlow College school to the type of students who go there for the issues most important to them. While the series only has a small amount of humor directed at how “woke” today’s youth are, it leans heavily into humor about how things that were appropriate a decade ago can cause you a lot of problems now – an element that… Vladimira show I didn’t even enjoy, understands it on a much less superficial level.

Rooster The endless amusement cannot be surpassed. No matter how well-intentioned Greg is, he is constantly sent to the disciplinary board for perfectly reasonable things like accidentally groping a student, accidentally exposing a student’s body, and other bits of casual antiquated behavior. Carell is very good at playing the withdrawn, unassuming side of Greg’s character, which makes him a disappointment every time the series tires of his somewhat antithetical meekness and turns him into a bumbling sitcom hero – with intentional or unintentional nods to… The office, 40 year old virgin And Carell’s other comedies, instead of pushing him into it Little Miss Sunshine-Depressive depth level.

Carell has good chemistry with all the actors, including McGinley in one of his gruff but likeable roles. Deadwyler, adorable every time Rooster remembers its existence; and Clive, whose Katie struggles to find her identity after her Russian studies professor husband (Archie Phil Dunster) cheats on her with a graduate student — not… for him The show confirms that she’s a graduate student, though it would be pointless to explain what kind of graduate student she is — her name is Sunny (Lauren Tsai).

Like Carell, Clive is very good in British soaps pure – The script would be better off asking her to play less overt comedy, and she’s constantly doing embarrassing or even illegal things just to get justice with Archie, whom the show tries in vain to treat as a likable man rather than a flirtatious scoundrel. You can feel Lawrence recalling how Dunster miraculously brought sympathetic shades to Jimmy Tartt in Ted Lasso He hopes he can do the same here. So far, it doesn’t work, though Tsai is able to turn her “other woman” persona into something more. Plus, Sunny has a roommate played by Robbie Hoffman, and all things are better with a dose of Robbie Hoffman — even things when she doesn’t quite know what to do with Robbie Hoffman.

The ensemble is full of relatively underutilized performers, big stars like Connie Britton, appearing in one episode as the wealthy wife who breaks Greg’s heart; Alan Ruck, as a college administrator who is treated like a gruff dinosaur so that Walt McGinley seems less like a dinosaur; Scott MacArthur, as an out-of-control hockey coach; And Annie Mumolo as an assistant who takes care of Greg. Among the not-so-instantly recognizable cast, Máximo Salas steals a number of scenes as a bumbling student whom Greg takes under his wing.

Rooster He has such a good staff that I was able to do many things Sometimes I forget how much the show’s overt attempts at humor fail — plus all the ways it comes off as creepy or weird without ever achieving the level of heart necessary to earn those extended scenes in Walt’s sauna on the front porch or Greg’s inappropriate gaffes. Lawrence’s lineage makes me confident that if Rooster Whoever knows which of the many high-concept shows he wants and then leaves that high concept behind to let the group cook, will do well. But through six episodes, I was always aware of how much potential he had still buried.